Question: Simplify Fraction with Powers

Comment on Simplify Fraction with Powers

Hey Brent!
What is wrong with this approach:
breaking up to ((6*4)^5 . (4*3)^3)/(6^6 . (4*4)^4 which turned out to be 9/6=3/2
gmat-admin's picture

Hi Abrahamic01,

The first part of your solution looks good: ((6*4)^5 * (4*3)^3)/(6^6)*(4*4)^4

I'd have to see the rest of your calculations, to see how you arrived at the answer of 3/2

Hi Brent,
In this question, when it says "If x is positive", it tells me right away that I need to test integer and none integer positive values, so I tested 2, 3 and 1/2, but it didn't come to my mind to test another fraction like what you did when you tested 3/4.
My question is, how you decide what values to choose to test, does it have anything to do with the sense, I mean, as you are expert and specialized in math, so by experience the suitable values will jump to your mind or how?
Because the question looks easy, but if I don't test the right values, I will end up choose the wrong answer.
gmat-admin's picture

Question link:

Great question, Aladdin.

Since there are 3 possible orderings, we should be prepared to plug in at least 3 sets of values.

However, as you have noted, it's hard to tell which values to plug in (other than an integer value and a fractional value).

If x = 3/4 had not yielded a "nice" result (i.e., identifying another possible ordering), I would have tried a couple more different values.

This highlights the shortcomings of plugging in numbers.

As you can see, Mitch's post (below my post at the linked question above) uses a different approach that relies on CRITICAL POINTS to help determine the correct answer.

In the following article, I write about the shortcomings of plugging in answer choices with respect to Data Sufficiency questions, but I think it applies here as well:

(1/6)(3^3)= 9/6 = 3/2

whats wrong with this approach?
gmat-admin's picture

Your approach is perfect right up until the last calculation.
3^3 = 27 (not 9)

Scoring Algorithm

The GMAT scoring algorithm penalizes you much more for getting easy questions wrong than it rewards you for getting difficult questions right. So, it’s better to guess on hard questions so you’ll have enough time to answer easier questions.

Change Playback Speed

You have the option of watching the videos at various speeds (25% faster, 50% faster, etc). To change the playback speed, click the settings icon on the right side of the video status bar.

Free “Question of the Day” emails!