Lesson: Introduction to Square Roots

Comment on Introduction to Square Roots

Can you please help me with this one ?

Is x > y ?
(1) ✓x > y
(2) x² > y
gmat-admin's picture

Tricky question! Just curious, what's the source?

TARGET QUESTION: Is x > y?

STATEMENT 1: ✓x > y
There are several values x and y that satisfy statement 1. Here are two:
CASE A: x = 9 and y = 2 (notice that ✓9 = 3, and 3 is greater than 2. In this case, x > y
CASE B: x = 1/4 and y = 0.3 (notice that ✓(1/4) = 1/2, and 1/2 is greater than 0.3. In this case, x < y
Since we cannot answer the TARGET QUESTION with certainty, statement 2 is NOT sufficient.

STATEMENT 2: x² > y
There are several values x and y that satisfy statement 2. Here are two:
CASE A: x = 3 and y = 2 (notice that 3² = 9, and 9 is greater than 2. In this case, x > y
CASE B: x = 3 and y = 4 (notice that 3² = 9, and 9 is greater than 4. In this case, x < y
Since we cannot answer the TARGET QUESTION with certainty, statement 2 is NOT sufficient.

STATEMENTS 1 and 2 COMBINED
It's easy to show values of x and y that satisfy BOTH statements where x > y. For example, the following values of x and y satisfy BOTH statements:
x = 100 and y = 1
x = 16 and y = 1
x = 25 and y = -3
x = 1 and y = -30
etc
In all of the above cases, x > y
So, the correct answer MAY be C.

That said, the answer will E if there are values of x and y that satisfy BOTH statements AND where x < y

Is it possible to find such values for x and y?
No.

The tricky part is finding finding a situation where ✓x > y YET x < y

Important concept: in most cases, the square root of a number is less than the original number. For example:
✓9 < 9
✓4 < 4
✓36 < 36
The only time ✓x is GREATER THAN x is when 0 < x < 1. For example:
✓(1/4) > 1/4
✓(1/25) > 1/25
etc

So, if 0 < x < 1 then ✓x > x
The problem is that, if 0 < x < 1 then x² < x
So, any value on this range will satisfy statement 1, but will NOT satisfy statement 2.
As such, we CANNOT find values for x and y that satisfy BOTH statements such that x < y

So, it MUST be the case that, when both statements are combined, x > y

Answer: C

Thanks Brent :)

Hi Brent,
I couldn't find your answer to this question:
https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-x-and-y-are-positive-which-of-the-following-must-be-82080.html
Please let me know if it is already somewhere, if not, I would appreciate if you help and answer it, :
My answer is D. I and II only
There is too much debates there, it was confusing for me.
Thanks
Aladdin
gmat-admin's picture

Hi Aladdin,

Here's my step-by-step solution: https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-x-and-y-are-positive-which-of-the-followin...

Cheers,
Brent

Thank you so much.

Hi Brent, could you please help me come up with a faster solution for the question below?

If x and y are positive, which of the following must be greater than 1x+y−−−−√1x+y?

I. x+y−−−−√2x+y2
II. x√+y√2x+y2
III. x√−y√x+yx−yx+y

A. I only
B. II only
C. III only
D. I and II only
E. None
gmat-admin's picture

Hi Jalaj,

I'd love to help you, but some of your entries are confusing and/or ambiguous.

For example, in statement I (x+y−−−−√2x+y2), is the square root over BOTH 2x and y²?

Likewise, in statement II (x√+y√2x+y2), what is inside the first square root symbol? It looks empty.

If possible, it would be great if you could find the question online and send me the link.
Alternatively, please add some brackets and spaces to prevent ambiguity.

By the way, what's the source of this question?

Cheers,
Brent

Hi Brent, below is the source of the question. My apologies for the confusion.

https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-x-and-y-are-positive-which-of-the-following-must-be-82080.html
gmat-admin's picture

That helps a lot.
Here's my full solution: https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-x-and-y-are-positive-which-of-the-followin...

Cheers,
Brent

https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-7x-1-2-an-integer-145680.html
sir can you please explain this?
gmat-admin's picture

Hi Brent, do you agree with the answer on GMAT club? How can the answer be statement 1 is sufficient?

Is 7x−−√7x an integer?
(1) x7−−√x7 is an integer
(2) 28x−−−√28x is an integer

(1) Atleast 2 values of x can satisfy this condition
x=7 and x=343.

How can the answer be statement 1 is sufficient?

Similary for statement 2 x=1/28 and x=7 satisfies the condition

so if we combine 2 statements we get x=7 since x=1/28 will not satisfy statement 1!

Answer should be C right?
gmat-admin's picture

I'm happy to help.

ASIDE: In the future, please post a link to the question. I had a hard time finding the question (here it is https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-7x-1-2-an-integer-145680.html)

The correct answer is A.

Here's my full solution: https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-7x-1-2-an-integer-145680.html#p2152171

Cheers,
Brent

I had already checked your solution!
Its a different approach. Can you please tell me whats wrong with my approach?


For statement 1. Atleast 2 values of x can satisfy this condition
x=7 and x=343...so how is this sufficient?
gmat-admin's picture

Question link: https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-7x-1-2-an-integer-145680.html

TARGET QUESTION: Is √(7x) an integer?

STATEMENT 1: √(x/7) is an integer
You're right to say that x = 7 and x = 343 both satisfy statement 1.
HOWEVER, the target question doesn't ask us to determine the value of x; the target question asks us to determine whether √(7x) is an integer.

Let's test your two results (x = 7 and x = 343)
If x = 7, then √(7x) = √(49) = 7. So, the answer to the target question is "YES, √(7x) IS an integer".
If x = 343, then √(7x) = √(2401) = 49. So, the answer to the target question is "YES, √(7x) IS an integer".

There also are other x-values that satisfy statement 1.
For example, x = 28 also works. So does x = 63

Let's test these results as well
If x = 28, then √(7x) = √(196) = 14. So, the answer to the target question is "YES, √(7x) IS an integer".
If x = 63, then √(7x) = √(441) = 21. So, the answer to the target question is "YES, √(7x) IS an integer".

Notice that, even though there are infinitely many x-values that satisfy statement 1, when we test each of these possible x-values, the answer to the target question is ALWAYS the same: "YES, √(7x) IS an integer".
In other words, it MUST be the case that √(7x) IS an integer.

Since we can answer the target question with absolute certainty, statement 1 is sufficient.

KEY TAKEAWAY: Our goal is to determine whether each statement provides enough information to answer the target question with absolute certainty.

Does that help?

Cheers,
Brent

Thanks Brent! So the target question should not satisfy different values. In this case its "is" or "is not" an integer. If the Q was find value of x so it was not sufficient.

I think with my approach would be time consuming since I have to keep searching values of x for which it will not satisfy. There is no limit to the search. Will stick to your approach.
gmat-admin's picture

That's correct. IF the target question asked "What is the value of x?" then statement 1 would not be sufficient.

Here are two example to highlight the key concept:
--------------------
TARGET QUESTION: If x is an integer, is x ODD?
Statement 1: x is a prime number greater than 2.

Even though there are infinitely many prime numbers greater than 2 (e.g., 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, etc), we know that ALL prime number greater than 2 are ODD.
So, the answer to the target question is "YES, x is most definitely odd"
Statement 1 is sufficient.
--------------------
TARGET QUESTION: If x is an integer, what is the value of x?
Statement 1: x is a prime number greater than 2.

In this case, we cannot answer the target question with certainty, since x can be 3 or 5 or 7 or 11 or 13 or . . .
Statement 1 is not sufficient.

Cheers,
Brent

Thanks Brent
Sorry, one final time going back to the original question from GMAT club, this time for statement 2. the approach used is testing some values of x. But can we not use the same approach as we did for statement 1 which is solving the equation?
So it will go as:
let integer be p
so √(28x)=p
square both sides
28x=p²
7.4x=p²
7x=(p²)/4
take square root both sides
√(7x)=p/2=0.5p...not an integer

Not sufficient?
gmat-admin's picture

Question link: https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-7x-1-2-an-integer-145680.html

Great idea!
I'd make just one small change to your approach:

At the end, once we know that √(7x) = p/2, we can't conclude that p/2 is NOT an integer.
For example, if p = 14, then p/2 IS an integer.
Conversely, if p = 3, then p/2 is NOT an integer.

Now that we have two contradictory answers to the target question, we can be certain that statement 2 is not sufficient.

Cheers,
Brent

Oh yes, thanks for the heads up!
Not sufficient implies not getting a unique solution! we need atleast one "not" and atleast one "is" an integer
gmat-admin's picture

Exactly!

Hi Brent,

say we have
1/x= 1/(x+15)+ 1/(x-4)

The on solving this we get
x^2= -60
Does this mean there is no solution for x
gmat-admin's picture

That's correct; the equation x² = -60 has no real solutions.

Cheers,
Brent

Add a comment

Office Hours

Have questions about your preparation or an upcoming test? Need help modifying the Study Plan to meet your unique needs? No problem. Just book a Skype meeting with Brent to discuss these and any other questions you may have. 

Change Playback Speed

You have the option of watching the videos at various speeds (25% faster, 50% faster, etc). To change the playback speed, click the settings icon on the right side of the video status bar.

Have a question about this video?

Post your question in the Comment section below, and I’ll answer it as fast as humanly possible.

Free “Question of the Day” emails!